Was Winston Churchill actually incompetent

The "Big Three" from Yalta were very sick

The world did not know how bad it really was for the three heads of state during the Yalta conference. Only the personal physicians who accompanied the 700-strong delegations had precise knowledge of the state of health of the "Big Three".

Franklin D. Roosevelt (1882 to 1945) suffered from poliomyelitis from the age of 39 and was paralyzed from the hip. He also had a serious heart condition. By the end of 1944 he was severely physically weakened. Roosevelt's personal physician, Dr. Ross McIntire, an ear, nose and throat specialist at Naval Hospital, drew cardiologist Dr. Howard Bruenn of Bethesda Marine Hospital for advice. Bruenn found hypertension with peaks of 240/130 mmHg.

The illustrious patient was in a generally disastrous state of health: he suffered from frequent abdominal cramps, was very pale (Hb value known since 1941 around 4.5 g / dl) and had lost a lot of weight. McIntire, who also led the US medical team in Yalta, was later blamed for not allowing Roosevelt to drive. The US president only survived the Yalta conference by two months.

That Roosevelt was actually incapable of conducting the negotiations in Yalta annoyed and incriminated Winston Churchill (1874-1965). The British Prime Minister himself was badly ill health, as his personal physician Dr. Charles Wilson Lord Moran himself published in a biography of his patient published in 1966. Churchill ate and drank inordinately. He also smoked a chain.

Until 1940 he had never been seriously ill. But then he had to pay tribute to his lifestyle. In December 1941 he had his first serious heart attack, and two years later the second. The symptoms of coronal and, above all, cerebral insufficiency are increasingly affecting Churchill. Even before the Yalta conference he was looking nervous, listless, unfocused and exhausted. In Yalta he had problems following the negotiations, as Lord Moran wrote.

Josef W. Stalin (1879 to 1953) was by no means healthy either, but his constitution was better. He is also considered to be the real winner of Yalta. Stalin was a paranoid, suspicious, lonely man who suffered from various phobias. He hated all doctors. His iatrophobia could, however, have had a real background, as his daughter Svetlana suspects in her memoirs: She assumes that the paralysis of the left arm and shoulder, from which Stalin suffered since childhood, was the result of a medical malpractice.

Stalin's personal physician was the internist Dr. Vladimir Vinogradov. But he only received treatment in an emergency and did not follow the therapies. Documentation about Stalin's health was strictly forbidden to the doctor. All that is known is that Stalin was hypertensive. He later had Vinogradov arrested along with other doctors.

A terminally ill, a cerebral insufficiency and a paranoid were the "Big Three" negotiating the future of Europe in Yalta.